HONOLULU — On Kaua‘i, where sprawling, white-sand beaches and dramatic seaside mountains attract visitors from around the world, local residents spent the first seven months of the pandemic sheltered from the viral storm.
Early and aggressive local measures coupled with a strictly-enforced, statewide travel quarantine kept Kaua‘i’s 72,000 residents mostly healthy — the island had only 61 known coronavirus cases from March through September. But on Oct. 15, the state launched a pre-travel testing program to reignite Hawai‘i’s decimated tourism economy.
Kaua‘i then went from having no active infections at all in the first part of October to at least 84 new cases in the ensuing seven weeks. The surge seeded community transmission and led to the island’s first — and so far only — COVID-19 death: Ron Clark, who worked for decades as a tour driver.
Despite Hawai‘i’s cautious effort at reopening that allowed travelers who tested negative for COVID-19 before they flew to the state to sidestep quarantine rules, the Kaua‘i spike illustrates the difficulty of preserving public health — even on an isolated island — when economic recovery relies on travel.
Kaua‘i officials have decided the cost of vacationing in paradise, for now, is too high.
Clark got COVID-19 in November and died about 10 days later. At age 84, he worked until he contracted the disease and most recently shuttled airline pilots and crews to and from Lihu‘e Airport. Airline crews are exempt from the state’s testing and quarantine rules.
The day after Clark’s death, Kaua‘i officials said they would opt out of the state’s testing program and require visitors to again quarantine for two weeks whether or not they test negative for COVID-19 before arriving.
Kaua‘i officials say the single-test scheme did not do enough to protect the people who live there. With only nine ICU beds and 14 ventilators, the island’s health-care system could quickly become overwhelmed by a large outbreak, said Mayor Derek Kawakami.
Seeking to prevent such a scenario, Kawakami proposed a mandatory second test for all passengers after arrival. His plan would have included a short quarantine while people awaited their second result.
“We think having a negative test is a good prerequisite to getting on a plane,” Kawakami said. But “once you land on Kaua‘i … (travelers) should be able to sit and cool off for three days.”
But the proposal was turned down by state officials, with Democratic Gov. David Ige saying the plan would have to be locally funded and administered.
After the Kaua‘i surge, the state Department of Health traced most of the island’s October and November cases to returning residents and tourists who brought the virus in despite the pre-flight testing program.
JoAnn Yukimura, former Kaua‘i mayor and friend of Clark’s for more than three decades, said his death shook the community, and that she constantly thinks “of him being alone at the hospital. How lonely it must have been to die.”
“Ron’s death might seem to outsiders like such a small matter,” Yukimura said. But it “hit us hard because we on Kaua‘i haven’t become inured to death and sickness — and we don’t ever want to get that way.”
Before the pandemic, Hawai‘i welcomed about 30,000 tourists daily, who spent nearly $18 billion last year.
In March, when the state’s two-week quarantine rule was imposed, tourist arrivals and revenue plummeted. Visitor numbers have since increased with the testing program, but only to about a third of pre-pandemic levels.
On Kaua‘i, 57-year-old Edwin Pascua has been unemployed from his hotel bellhop job since March, and worries about having contact with infected travelers — but would rather be working.
“If there are safeguards in place, that would lessen everything,” he said. “I wouldn’t be as afraid.”
Pascua and his wife, who works at the same hotel, have gotten by with unemployment benefits. But he knows people who “haven’t even gotten a check yet, one check from unemployment.”
Despite the new infection surge and record deaths on the mainland, top Hawai‘i officials insist that the pre-travel testing program works.
“The proof is in the pudding,” Lt. Gov. Josh Green said. “Hawai‘i has the lowest rate of COVID in the country because of this program right now.”
Hawai‘i enjoys relatively low hospitalization and death rates, but health experts said because of the way COVID-19 accumulates in the body over time, second tests for travelers would weed out more infection.
Dr. Kapono Chong-Hanssen, a Native Hawaiian physician who runs a Kaua‘i community health center, said the single test requirement “goes against the medical evidence.”
“We’re starting to see these big holes in the plan, and I think it’s a matter of time before we pay the price,” he said.
There have been more than 380 travel-related infections in Hawai‘i since the testing program was launched, according to the DOH.
The real number of infections among the general population is believed to be far higher than what has been reported. Many asymptomatic people, who can still spread the disease, do not get tested.
Dr. Ashish Jha, dean of the school of public health at Brown University, said travel restrictions for most places at this point in the pandemic are “either counter-productive or relatively useless,” and can give a false sense of security.
“There is evidence that international travel bans are helpful at slowing things down,” Jha said. But “unless you seal your country off completely and do it early, it’s pretty tough to use that as a strategy.”
Kaua‘i, isolated by the ocean and largely protected by early restrictions, had done just that.
When the original quarantine rule was in effect, Kaua‘i residents went to restaurants, schools were open and locals spent their money in the community. That might happen again with Kaua‘i’s reinstatement of the quarantine rule amid hopes by locals that the community will remain healthy.
Travel “introduces a continuous stream of new infections,” said Dr. Janet Berreman, district health officer for the DOH Kaua‘i District Health Office.
“This tsunami, if you will, of disease,” she said, “has marched across the mainland, from east to west. We’re just a little farther west across a body of water. But everybody wants to come here for the holidays.”
