Logout|My Dashboard
  • Subscribe

Shiva Shiva brings anti-GMO message to Kaua‘i

Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

Related YouTube Video

Posted: Saturday, January 19, 2013 1:00 am

LIHU‘E — The Kaua‘i War Memorial Convention Hall was standing room only as more than 1,100 people showed up Thursday night to hear a presentation by environmentalist Dr. Vandana Shiva.

“Your island is truth speaking to the world,” Shiva told the crowd to thunderous applause.

Joining Shiva as part of a three-day Hawai‘i SEED Tour was environmental attorney Andrew Kimbrell and Hawaiian rights activist Walter Ritte of Moloka‘i.

“Dr. Shiva is like the Dalai Lama of Agriculture,” Ritte said of the Indian philosopher, physicist, environmental activist and eco-feminist who has authored more than 20 books. As a leader in the International Forum of Globalization, Shiva fights for changes in the practices and paradigms of food, according to her biography.

Shiva met with residents of the Westside for dinner ahead of time to discuss a pending class action lawsuit over the continued experimental use of pesticides by biotech companies in the area.

Because of the experiments taking place with pesticides and genetically engineered seeds on the Westside of the island, Kaua‘i is considered ground zero internationally in the fight to stop biotech companies such as Monsanto, Dow, DuPont, Bayer and Syngenta from creating more products and patenting more seeds.

Organizers are also working to have Hawai‘i become the first state to label foods containing genetically modified organisms.

In assisting grassroots organizations in the green movement worldwide, Shiva has been featured in several documentaries and received the Right Livelihood Award and the Global 500 Award of the United Nations Environmental Program. She has been called one of the five most powerful women in Asia.

Along with Shiva was Andrew Kimbrell, who became the executive director of the International Center for Technology Assessment in 1994 and the executive director of the Center for Food Safety in 1997. As one of the leading environmental attorneys in the nation, he has authored several books on the environment, technology in society and food issues. In 1994, Utne Reader named him as one of the world’s leading visionaries.

Sponsored by Hawai‘i SEED, The Center for Food Safety and Navdanya, the evening discussing the elimination of genetically modified organisms, along with the labeling of GMO products, was the culmination of a three-day long Hawai‘i SEED Tour that had Shiva, Kimbrell and Ritte speaking to a sold out audiences at the University of Hawai‘i at Manoa and at the Kapolei Salvation Army Ray Kroc Center, along with legislative briefings and presentations in the State Capitol by Kaua‘i County Councilman Gary Hooser, Sen. Laura Thielen and others.

At the outset of the evening, vendors from around the island set up a seed giveaway featuring a local farming resource fair and silent auction to benefit Hawai‘i SEED.

Emceeing the Kaua‘i event was Nancy Redfeather of Kawanui Farm on the Big Island, who in her work as a teacher and gardener has helped create 65 school gardens through her work as program director for the Hawai‘i Island School Garden Network and is the director of the Hawai‘i Public Seed Initiative.

Opening the evening at the Kaua‘i War Memorial were students from Kanu I Ka Pono New Century Public Charter School, who greeted the audience with chant and poetry.

“There’s room for man’s need, but not man’s greed,” said one Kanu I Ka Pono student in her poem, paraphrasing Mahatma Gandhi.

Up next was performer Makana, who played a modified version of his “We Are the Many” anthem advising the crowd to “Occupy GMO.” He also performed a new song titled, “The Story of the GMO,” which addresses the history of the anti-GMO movement and closed the evening with an untitled “Song for Vandana,” that he was inspired to write while listening to Shiva’s presentation.

In introducing Dr. Shiva, Redfeather said Dr. Shiva has trained more than 650,000 farmers in India and is advising Bhutan on how to be come the first wholly organic country in the world.

“I was told you were a very small island with a very small population. It doesn’t look like it when you stand in this hall,” she said.

She said that the myth was that spraying pesticides has lead to the rise of GMOs.

Dr. Shiva said farmers were told they would never have to spray again, “we known through the practice in the rest of the world that in fact the spray increases and you talk about it. The GMOs are not a safe alternative to poisons. They are pushed by the poison industry to increase poison sales and monopolize the seed industry.”

In discussing the 1984 Bhopal disaster, Dr. Shiva said 3,000 people died in a gas leak from a Union Carbide plant and more than 30,000 people have died since then. She said the disaster didn’t stop after the explosion “as generations being born today are being born crippled.”

She said Bhopal isn’t the only poison tragedy in India. She said 1,000 people died in the past couple years in “the endosulfan tragedy,” when thousands of people were sprayed with pesticides that went into water and wells.

Dr. Shiva said India’s Green Revolution started off with chemicals that were designed for killing people in times of war. After World War II, these companies then turned the chemicals into pesticides and now have become a biotech.

“The explosive factories were redesigned to create fertilizer,” Dr. Shiva said, noting that the Oklahoma bombing, the Oslo bombing and every bombing in India were created using fertilizer bombs.

“We delivered sacks and sacks of fertilizer to the Afghans and now they are making bombs,” she said of the Central Intelligence Agency providing fertilizer to the country. “A century of war making and destruction is behind this.”

Her research for the United Nations also uncovered that nerve gas was being modified into modern day pesticides.

She addressed her plans to organize new Nuremberg Trials to go after the companies making nerve gas to kill people during World War II that are still making chemicals today.

“We are going to organize new Nuremberg trials and bring together everyone that has been harmed in the name of agricultural progress,” she said.

Dr. Shiva went on to say she was at a conference where people were talking about making seed saving a crime. She said one of the big fights being faced is to prevent the criminalization of seed saving by farmers.

“How could it be that the death industry can recreate itself as the life sciences industry?” she asked, adding that the companies position themselves as patient and diagnostician for a problem, with the problem being farmers saving seeds.

She said that growing up, her family used the neem tree for pest control, which causes bugs to reproduce slower. She said the neem tree is called the “village farmer,” and has more than 1,000 uses.

After Bhopal, Dr. Shiva delivered neem trees to the area and made posters that read, “No more Bhopals. Plant a Neem.”

She discussed other biopiracy cases such as basmati rice, which RiceTec patented and claimed to have invented along with how worldwide trade impacts the industry.

“Everything comes from China,” Dr. Shiva said of the U.S. being in a negative trade balance. “Patented seeds and GMO crops are the only things leaving. You have become the nerve center for this destruction.”

In the end, though, Dr. Shiva said the biotech companies have left us with bug-resistant super pests and super wheats.

“The GMO emperor has no clothes,” Dr. Shiva said. “We have the clarity to speak truth. We do not recognize patents on life.”

Monopolies and monocultures go together and have reduced to just eight commodities including animal feed, biofuel and human food last. She said it wastes communities by destroying them and imposes uniformity along with shipping them in trucks.

“Food is a waste system. It wastes the Earth, it wastes communities, it wastes potential, they ship it thousands of miles in trucks,” she said.

“Bees usurp pollen, weeds steal sunshine … everyone is a thief in their world because they are the thieves,” Dr. Shiva said of what the biotech companies are telling the world, “This is not about technology. This is about conquest. That’s why every time a religion has conquered, they destroyed sacred shrines and put in churches.”

She said people should live by the tenets of Gandhi, including satyagraha meaning fight for truth; swaraj meaning self-organized freedom; and swadeshi, meaning self-making as a rule of freedom; and the concept of lifting up everyone including the most vulnerable.

In the end, Dr. Shiva called on Kaua‘i’s residents to work on feeding themselves.

“You have so much water and biodivesity here on the Garden Island that it should be a garden and in reality feeding itself.”

See Sunday’s edition of The Garden Island for more on Walter Ritte and Andrew Kimbrell’s presentations Thursday night.

• Laurie Cicotello, business writer, can be reached at 245-3681 (ext. 257) or business@thegardenisland.com

© 2015 Thegardenisland.com. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

More about

Rules of Conduct

  • 1 Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
  • 2 Don't Threaten or Abuse. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated. AND PLEASE TURN OFF CAPS LOCK.
  • 3 Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
  • 4 Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
  • 5 Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
  • 6 Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.

Welcome to the discussion.


  • Leialoha posted at 2:24 pm on Mon, Jan 21, 2013.

    Leialoha Posts: 15

    Aloha! Wow Garden Island Newspaper! Mahalo for being present with this historic event. and reporting so well!! This Event with Aunty Vandana, Uncle Walter and Uncle Andy was amazing and important! I am glad 4 everyone there.

    @Merliee and everyone... Most of Vandnas Books are available for free, including studies etc... here the link to “The GMO emperor has no clothes,” Dr. Shiva said. “We have the clarity to speak truth. We do not recognize patents on life.” -


    (there is more if you vist her page)

    @Pete: you are blaming the blame.... and your opinion is based on "was reported in the article these comments are relating to" - well if you not been there or followed it live and felt the message you will have chances to to this soon. The talk will be available soon in video form, KCCR did it live on thier radio and i think they have a archive on their website... Please show respect and look a little deeper and foremost for yourself

  • PeteAntonson posted at 2:58 am on Mon, Jan 21, 2013.

    PeteAntonson Posts: 2511


    1) You really need to look up the definition of racism. It does not include debunking the opinions stated as facts of someone; even if that someone is a person of color. It does not include denigrating the poverty crushing corruption of politicians of another country.

    2) The finger pointing was reported in the article these comments are relating to.

    3) Duuuuuhhhh!

  • da1wahine posted at 1:04 pm on Sun, Jan 20, 2013.

    da1wahine Posts: 6

    I seldom see such blatant racism publicly displayed as in Pete's comment. BTW, IF you'd been there at the presentation, Pete (and I suspect you weren't), you would have deduced a sense of unity of purpose, not finger pointing by Dr Shiva. "Blame" is entirely off the track- we need to focus on cleaning things up, and that is the responsibility of ALL of us! Each one of us can do SOMETHING to make a change. Go sign a petition, at least!

  • PeteAntonson posted at 10:35 pm on Sat, Jan 19, 2013.

    PeteAntonson Posts: 2511

    Who owned and managed the corporation that operated the Bhopal plant in complete violation of Union Carbide plant operating procedures?


    Who shut down or allowed to break down all the fail-safe devices in the plant design?


    Whose government failed to enforce even one of its own safety regulations?


    Whose government allowed the Indian owners to build this plant in a heavily populated area?


    What country's national and local leadership is a corrupt, lying, pack of thieves that provide 90% of the nightmare anecdotes used by antiGMO activists around the world?


    This is why, when pointing a finger at Kauai, three of her fingers point right back at her!

  • kealiahana posted at 5:25 pm on Sat, Jan 19, 2013.

    kealiahana Posts: 289

    Where was the mayor and local leaders ? Did not see them in the crowd?

  • kealiahana posted at 5:22 pm on Sat, Jan 19, 2013.

    kealiahana Posts: 289

    I am against all who abuse this island and its people with synthetic chemicals and synthetic philosophy. Yes we know all this stuff in our soil is bad. But where did it come from and why? Is this any different the US military is using the island and state as well. Does Kaua'i really need these big corporations who soil our soil with chemicals and the military maiking us a target? Furthermore do we really need an outsider PHD or not tell us what is good for us? Isn't this how it happenned in the first place? I just want to breathe the fresh air, surf in clean waters, drink rainwater, eat food from natural soil, whoa forgot thats the way it once was. Before we talk lets look around and in the mirror.

  • kauaiboy posted at 3:18 pm on Sat, Jan 19, 2013.

    kauaiboy Posts: 276

    A woman...

    a globalist...

    and a PHD in Philosophy...

    EXACTLY who I want to be telling the USA how to run its business!

    She sure beats the profit-at-any-cost greed mongers who justify everything greedy thing they do by saying it is their duty to the shareholders.

    So, manoaborn, please enlighten us fools. How exactly did Al Gore sell out to Big Oil? And how many air and SUV miles do you think the environmentalist have racked up compared to the greedy corporate polluters? 1/2 of 1% as many? Get a clue. GMOs are bad news for the world, but they are especially bad news for Kauai.

  • cousin posted at 10:30 am on Sat, Jan 19, 2013.

    cousin Posts: 20

    Kauai'i' is called the Garden Island for the years it supplied the Hawaiian Islands with vegetables, fruits, dairy, beef and all things grown. Now Kaua'i' is hosting the GMO monster laboratories and the fields of Frankenfood.

    We can look forward to the loss of indigenous life forms, genetically compromised crops forever lost from nature, and an island rendered forever polluted with GMO pollen.

    Kaua'i is remote from the mainlands of the Pacific and is likely why it is the chosen location for experimentation with GMO pollens.

    Just as the West Coast fears the poisons of the San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station if it is restarted next month, we may loose the West Coast to a nuclear disaster, just as Kaua'i' may loose the life forms of natural selection for what, corporate greed and inhumane culture?

    The GMO Emperor and all Global Corporations have no clothes. There is no gray area between nature and the total war against natural processes waged by Global Corporate enterprises.

  • manoaborn posted at 9:51 am on Sat, Jan 19, 2013.

    manoaborn Posts: 159

    She's a globalist with a Phd in philosophy. Just the person I want to be telling the US how to run its business.

    All you folks who worship at the altar of Gaia, what do you tell yourselves when one of your heroes, Al Gore, sells out to Big Oil?

    How do you justify all those environmentalists who fly around the world with their own entourages in their private jets and SUV calvacades?

    It's all hypocrisy.

  • Merilee posted at 2:56 am on Sat, Jan 19, 2013.

    Merilee Posts: 3

    “The GMO emperor has no clothes,” Dr. Shiva said. “We have the clarity to speak truth. We do not recognize patents on life.”



Online poll


Most Popular

Follow us on Facebook